How to Reduce Behavioral Health Claim Denials Without Adding More Work for Staff 

A claim comes back from the insurance company and now someone from billing has to figure out why. Maybe the authorization wasn’t updated or there’s a note missing from the patient’s chart. The claim was supposed to be finished last week but it’s back on the team’s list again. 

This happens often enough that staff can spend a good part of their week fixing claims they’ve already worked on. And when the same mistakes keep coming back, there’s not much point in telling everyone to be more careful. 

For behavioral health claim denials, it helps to look at what’s going wrong before the claims reach billing. Some of these problems can be handled without giving employees another long list of tasks. 

1. Find Out Why the Same Claims Keep Coming Back 

A billing employee fixes a denied claim and moves on. Later that week, billing gets another denial for a missing authorization. Other claims have coding errors or incorrect patient details. By the time one claim is corrected, there’s another waiting. Nobody has had a chance to look at why the same errors keep showing up. 

Go through the recent denials and see which reasons appear most. You don’t need a complicated report for this. Even a simple list of the denial reasons can give the team somewhere to start. 

If most claims are coming back because of authorization problems, that’s where the work needs attention. There’s no reason to change the entire billing process when one part keeps causing trouble. 

2. Check Insurance Details Before They Become a Problem 

Someone’s insurance was checked during admissions, so the billing team assumes everything is fine. But active insurance doesn’t always mean a particular treatment is covered. Some services need authorization and there may be limits the employee didn’t check during the first call. 

Then there’s the possibility of someone changing their plan during treatment. 

Staff need to confirm the coverage details that apply to the services being provided. Some of this information can be retrieved through insurance verification tools, although anything unclear still needs a closer look. 

It’s better to deal with those questions while the information is being collected than to find out about them after a claim has been denied. 

3. Don’t Let Authorizations Get Lost in Emails 

An authorization is approved for a certain period. Someone records the dates but a few weeks later, nobody remembers when it’s due for renewal. Maybe the employee who was tracking it is on leave. Or the approval was saved in an email that another department can’t access. 

Now the billing team has to work out what happened. Keeping authorization details in one place would make this easier. Staff need to see which services were approved, when that approval ends and who is handling the next request. Reminders can help here too. 

Instead of having someone open every record to check the dates, the system can flag approvals that are getting close to expiring. 

The employee still needs to deal with the payer but at least the deadline isn’t sitting unnoticed somewhere. 

4. Check the Chart Before Sending It to Billing 

A claim might have the right patient information and billing codes but still have a problem with the documentation. Perhaps the therapist hasn’t signed the note. Maybe the treatment plan wasn’t updated when it should have been. 

Billing may not notice until the payer asks for records or the claim gets denied. Then someone has to contact the clinical team and ask them to review what’s missing. 

A 2023 report from the HHS Office of Inspector General estimated that Medicare made $580 million in improper payments for psychotherapy services during the first year of the pandemic. The review found problems such as missing session times and provider signatures. 

At some centers, staff still have to open every chart and check it against a list. Staff may spend time reading through a chart only to find that everything is fine. And there could be another hundred waiting.  

An AI chart auditing tool can identify records with missing notes, signatures or other gaps, saving staff from having to search through every chart themselves. 

5. Stop Entering the Same Information Twice 

Ask someone from admissions where they record insurance details. Then ask billing where they get that information. Sometimes the answer is two different systems. 

An employee enters the patient’s details during intake and somebody from billing types them again later. That’s more work and there’s another chance to enter something incorrectly. It’s worth looking at which details staff keep copying from one place to another. 

If the systems can share information, that could save a few steps. Where they can’t, having everyone collect the information in the same format may help avoid confusion. 

The same goes for reminders and claim updates. Employees shouldn’t have to keep checking the same record just to find out whether anything has changed. 

6. When Only One Employee Knows the Payer Rules 

A claim is ready to go but the person handling it isn’t sure whether the payer needs another document. The employee who usually deals with that insurance company is off today. 

Now they’re looking through old emails or checking previous claims to find out what to send. 

Staff shouldn’t have to do this every time someone is away. A shared file with the requirements that come up most often would help. Nothing lengthy, just which documents are needed for certain services and where to check the current rules. 

The file needs updating whenever a payer changes something, though. Otherwise, the team could be working with instructions that are no longer correct. 

7. Did the Changes Actually Help? 

Say the team kept missing authorization renewals, so they started using reminders. A month has passed. Are fewer claims coming back because of authorization problems? 

Check the denials from before and after the reminders were introduced. Look at how much time employees are spending correcting those claims, too. 

If nothing has improved, find out what’s happening when the reminders arrive. Maybe they’re coming too late or the dates aren’t being updated. Perhaps everyone sees the reminder but nobody knows who’s handling it. 

Most billing systems already have reports that can help with this. There’s no reason to make employees spend another afternoon putting numbers into a spreadsheet. 

Final Thoughts 

There will still be claims that come back from payers, even after staff have checked everything. Sometimes another document is needed or someone has to call the insurance company to sort things out. 

But finding the same missing notes or expired authorizations week after week is a different problem.  

If behavioral health claim denials keep happening for the same reasons, the team needs to find out where things are going wrong. Otherwise, they’ll keep spending time fixing claims they thought were already finished. 

Explore more technology guides